Is this favorite modern classic as good as you remember? Porsche 997.2 vs 991.1 Carrera S comparo

Porsche Club of America
Jul 27, 2026, 8:00 pm12 pts
Nathan Merz compares two different generations of 911 Carrera S that are nearly the same spec. Many enthusiasts view the 997.2, model years 2009-2012, as peak water-cooled 911. Are they all wrong, particularly when a newer 991.1 costs about the same? (Video filmed in May 2026.) Click here to watch video In this…

Read Article Share
Share Article
- email
- x.com
- facebook
- pocket
- reddit
- tumblr
- linkedin
- pinterest

Trending Today on PCar.club

AutoEvolution

16-Year-Old Porsche 911 Turbo Takes On the New Chevy Corvette ZR1, You're In for a Surprise 64

Italian Firm Plans to Build Mid-Engine Porsche 911s

Rennlist

Italian Firm Plans to Build Mid-Engine Porsche 911s 58

AutoEvolution

Porsche's New Cayenne Electric Humiliates Ferrari Purosangue and Lamborghini Urus in a Straight Line 57

AutoEvolution

Thornley Kelham, a Specialist of Iconic Classic Cars, Brings to Life the 'Reimagined' Porsche 356 SL 39

The GT Killer That Never Was: Inside the Original Porsche 911R

Porsche Club of America

The GT Killer That Never Was: Inside the Original Porsche 911R 29

Laguna Seca 2026 | PCA Club Racing LIVE on PCA's YouTube August 1-2

Porsche Club of America

Laguna Seca 2026 | PCA Club Racing LIVE on PCA's YouTube August 1-2 21

Rare Carrera GT Customized by Gemballa Heads to Auction in Monterey

Rennlist

Rare Carrera GT Customized by Gemballa Heads to Auction in Monterey 15

Is this favorite modern classic as good as you remember? Porsche 997.2 vs 991.1 Carrera S comparo

Porsche Club of America

Is this favorite modern classic as good as you remember? Porsche 997.2 vs 991.1 Carrera S comparo 12

About PCar.club

Welcome to PCar.club the Porsche News Aggregator for sports car enthusiasts. Delivering a streamlined feed of Porsche automotive news daily.

Featured

Taycan and 911 Values Are Moving in…

Taycan and 911 Values Are Moving in Opposite Directions, But Not the Way You’d…

This New Italian Supercar Turns A…

This New Italian Supercar Turns A Porsche 911 Into An 800-HP Custom Machine

New Gran Turismo 7 Time Trial: Fresh Touring Origination

Porsche Carrera GT Races the Lexus LFA, and the Winner Takes It All

33 New Premium Diecast Collectibles Coming Up Soon

Nordicgoldmetallic Porsche Taycan Turbo GT Is a Whole New Level of Sonderwunsch…

Porsche Axes the Gas Macan at the Worst…

Porsche Axes the Gas Macan at the Worst Possible Time

Porsche Lights Up Goodwood Festival of…

Porsche Lights Up Goodwood Festival of Speed

The Biggest Strength and Biggest…

The Biggest Strength and Biggest Weakness of Every New Porsche Model

Porsche 911 and Lola T70 Are Selling to Recreate Iconic Scenes from McQueen’s…